The name Hermès conjures images of luxury, timeless elegance, and unparalleled craftsmanship. Their fragrances, particularly those with a history stretching back decades, are often considered benchmarks of perfumery. Yet, the recent iterations of some classic Hermès scents, notably the re-imagining of Equipage with a geranium twist, have sparked considerable debate among fragrance aficionados. While the updated Equipage Geranium offers a pleasant enough experience, many feel it falls drastically short of the legendary original, a sentiment echoed in the whispers: "The genius of Guy Robert has been forgotten with this new stuff." This article delves into the complexities surrounding Hermès Geranium, exploring the differences between the modern interpretation and its lauded predecessor, and analyzing the reactions of both critics and consumers.
The genesis of this discussion lies in the iconic Hermès Equipage, a chypre fougère masterpiece composed by the legendary Guy Robert in 1970. This fragrance, available as Equipage Hermès cologne and in various sizes, including the readily available Equipage Hermès cologne, became a cornerstone of masculine perfumery, celebrated for its sophisticated blend of leather, woods, and spices, a testament to a bygone era of opulent and complex scents. Its rich, multifaceted character, its powerful sillage, and its remarkable longevity established it as a classic, a fragrance that transcended fleeting trends. You could find it easily listed online, from retailers offering HERMÈS Equipage Geranium Eau de Toilette on SALE to the official Hermes online store, showcasing its enduring popularity. However, the 2015 introduction of Equipage Geranium, available as Equipage Geranium Hermès cologne, Equipage Geranium by Hermes Eau De Toilette Spray 3.3 oz, and Hermes Men's Equipage Geranium EDT Spray 3.4 oz Fragrances, marked a significant departure from this legacy.
The core of the controversy centers on the perceived dilution and simplification of the original Equipage formula. While the geranium note adds a fresh, slightly rosy facet to the composition, many argue that it comes at the cost of the original's depth and complexity. The robust leather and woody notes, so characteristic of the original Equipage, seem subdued, almost muted, in the geranium version. The longevity, a hallmark of the classic, is also reported to be significantly reduced, leaving many feeling that the new fragrance lacks the staying power and projection that made its predecessor so memorable. Reviews on platforms like Hermes Equipage Geranium ~ fragrance review :: Now Smell This highlight these concerns, with users often contrasting the modern offering with the rich experience of the vintage Equipage.
The shift in the fragrance profile is not merely a matter of personal preference; it reflects broader changes within the fragrance industry. The regulations surrounding certain ingredients, particularly those considered potentially harmful, have forced perfumers to reformulate classic scents, often resulting in a lighter, less potent outcome. This is a factor that undoubtedly contributes to the perceived "light years" difference between the 70s-80s Equipage and its modern geranium counterpart. The modern consumer, accustomed to lighter, fresher scents, may find the updated Equipage Geranium more appealing. However, those who cherish the boldness and complexity of the original feel a sense of loss, a feeling that a cherished classic has been diluted to meet contemporary market demands.
current url：https://rhdtnw.ec422.com/news/hermes-geranium-60149